Sticky Date Pudding Cake

posted by Holly Ford on Jan 23, 2014 (updated Oct 17, 2021) 13 comments »

If you want to taste a comforting English dessert, this sticky date pudding cake is a must try. Serve with warm caramel sauce. It’s heavenly!

Sticky date pudding cake is served with warm caramel sauce

The sticky date pudding cake that I tried at a small local pub in England was unforgettable. The moist cake was served with the warm caramel sauce, and I still remember how much I felt in love with the comforting English dessert.

Several years ago, I visited England out of the blue. My sister lived in Oxford at the time and I found a deal of the century to fly to England for USD $280 from Hong Kong (I was living in HK).

I was granted 10 days of vacation from my mother and wife duties. I booked the ticket and flew. We spent the 10 days together as sisters traveling to many lovely places in England.

Traveling to places without trying the local dishes is like eating cake without the icing. To be honest, I didn’t expect much regarding the food, but to my surprise, everything I tasted was just wonderful.

Out of all the delicious food I tried, this Sticky Date Pudding Cake (or Sticky Toffee Pudding) was the most unforgettable. Well, maybe because there was a memory behind this indulgent treat.

Sticky warm caramel sauce is poured on date pudding cake

It was in Canterbury. We visited the famous Canterbury cathedral and learned some of the great history of England. As we strolled down the street, my sister and I discovered a small chapel of the Church of England.

As far as I know the Church of England was established by King Henry VIII of England. There was a worship service underway in the chapel with a small group of people. Out of curiosity we went inside and listen to the sermon for 20 minutes.

Well, so far it sounds like a wonderful traveling experience, isn’t it? The problem began afterward. My sister and I developed a little argument over the characteristics of this church.

I thought that the service was similar to Catholic services but my sister thought it was more Protestant. We held fast to our small opinions and in our pride we eventually found ourselves in a great conflict over the political points of view of a king of England who lived 500 years ago.

We didn’t realize that our arguing voices were quite loud until we felt the glare of passers-by staring at us. (I think Henry VIII is a lucky guy to still be the main focus of conversation between two random southern Korean ladies who have nothing to do with him.)

Anyway, the arguing made us hungry, so we went into a random pub to dine with our feelings still irritated. We each ordered a different dish for dinner and then ate in silence while our tempers simmered. Then, to close a long day of contention with a sweet finale, we agreed to order a dessert to share.

You guessed it–it was this Sticky Date Pudding Cake. Oh, my! It was so good that we literally licked the plate. The melt-in-your-mouth pudding comforted the troubled hearts of two sisters from Korea. And it made us to soften our feelings to each other.

As we walked out of the pub, we became the best friends again, forgetting all about the ordeal we had before the meal. As you see, foods do bring people closer together. It gets even better if that involves a sweet treat. Don’t you think?

So here is the recipe. Don’t let the words “date” and “pudding” discourage you. It is a warm, gooey cake that even my picky, chocolate-loving children absolutely adore!

Date Pudding Cake

Chop the dates into small chunks.

Put the dates in a bowl and sprinkle in 1 teaspoon of baking soda. Pour boiling water and let it sit for 20 minutes to soften.

In another bowl whisk the flour, salt, and baking powder together.

Beat the butter and brown sugar in a mixer until creamy on medium speed.

Add the eggs, one at a time, and the vanilla. Beat until creamy and fluffy.

Add the flour and mix until incorporated on low speed.

Dump the dates and the water they were soaking in into the flour mixture.

Fold the dates into the flour mixture using a spoon until the batter is just mixed and smooth.

Pour the batter into a greased 7″ x 11″ baking pan, and shove it into a preheated 350 degree F. oven. Bake for 35-40 minutes.

Warm Caramel Sauce

Meanwhile let’s make the caramel sauce (or some may call it toffee sauce). Melt the butter, cream, brown sugar, and vanilla in a saucepan over medium heat.

Bring it to a gentle boil first. Then simmer it over low heat for 2 minutes.

When the cake is done, poke, poke, and poke everywhere!!! (I used a spaghetti noodle) You are making tunnels for the caramel sauce to permeate the cake.

Oh, yes! My dear! Drizzle 1/2 cup of the warm sauce over the warm cake. Reserve the rest of the sauce to top the cake with when ready to serve.

The pinnacle of sticky goodness is right here. The tender, soft, and almost pudding-like heaven…

This was the sweet treat that helped two adorable, middle-aged Korean ladies to reconcile over a conflict involving the King of England. And every time I make this cake, I will always remember His Majesty. (I sometimes wonder if King Henry and his 6 wives ever tried this cake.)

This is a truly comforting dessert for the cold days of winter. If you want an extra luxury, add a dollop of cream or vanilla ice cream on top. You will be flying to HEAVEN.

More Dessert Recipes